Open 24 hours, 7 days a week

Rekey Locks in Milwaukee — Fresh Keys, Same Hardware

Brew City Lock & Key rekeys home and business locks across the Milwaukee metro — old keys stopped, one fresh key issued, usually in a single visit. Call +1 (262) 314-8428 for a quote.

Rekeying: The Fastest Way to Take Back Your Keys

Rekeying changes the pins inside your existing locks so every old key stops working and a brand-new key takes over. You keep your hardware — you just take back control of who can open your doors.

When to Rekey

Rekey or Replace?

Rekey when the locks are healthy but the keys are compromised. Replace when locks are worn, damaged, or you want a security or style upgrade — we’ll tell you honestly which situation you’re in, and your quote reflects it.

What to Expect

Upfront quote before work begins

You approve the full price first — the quote is the price.

Non-destructive entry first

We pick and bypass before we ever consider drilling.

Real 24/7 dispatch

A real person answers at 3am just like at 3pm.

Mobile workshops

Key cutting and programming equipment on board every van.

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5 — based on 150 customer reviews across the Milwaukee metro.

Rekeying FAQs

Rekeying replaces the pins inside your existing lock so old keys no longer work and a new key does — the hardware stays, the key changes.

Yes — you pay for labor and pins rather than new hardware, which is why rekeying is the standard move after moving or losing keys.

Usually yes — locks that share a compatible keyway can all be pinned to a single key in one visit.

Most homes are done in a single visit; we bring all pinning kits and key blanks in the van and test every lock with you before leaving.

Yes — rekeying between tenants protects the new occupant, limits your liability, and costs far less than replacing hardware each turnover.

Related Pages

Locked out? We answer 24/7.

Call +1 (262) 314-8428 — a real dispatcher answers any hour with a straightforward quote before any work begins.

Call Now